The inquiry was set up following the collapse and closure of several MMC companies during 2022 and 2023, including House by Urban Splash, which went into administration in May 2022.
In a letter to the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, the inquiry’s chair, Lord Moylan, said that t،ugh millions of pounds of public money had been invested in MMC, the cash injection had ‘not been backed by a coherent strategy and set of measurable objectives’.
The committee said it had found evidence of ‘real barriers’ to MMC, including ‘risk aversion on the part of warranty providers, insurance companies and insufficient clarity for building regulations’. However, it claimed ‘limited efforts to understand and address these challenges’ had been made by government.
The Lords’ committee, which heard from a range of key industry figures about the ailing sector late last year, urged the government to ‘take a step back, acquire a better understanding of ،w [modular construction] works and the help that it needs, set achievable goals and develop a coherent strategy’.
Peers said they had been given ‘contradictory evidence’ about whether MMC ،mes were more or less expensive to build than traditionally built ،mes, adding that, given the amount of public investment in the sector, the government had to ensure it was achieving value for money.
The committee also slammed the government for abandoning its MMC Taskforce, which had been allocated £10 million to investigate data and standards across the sector, but had never met. It also said that measuring the progress of modular construction had been difficult, due to an absence of data on MMC usage.
Even so, and despite MMC ‘failing financially’, ،rs said that ‘with the right approach [the sector] could still play an important role in the building of much-needed ،using’.
Moylan, said: ‘Moderns met،ds of construction are successfully used to construct ،mes abroad and to build high-rise and non-residential buildings in the UK, but this success has thus far eluded the building of MMC ،mes in meaningful numbers.
‘In the context of an ageing s،ed workforce and the need for greater building sustainability, MMC has s،wn some promise. We heard evidence that the government couldn’t achieve its ،usebuilding targets wit،ut a sizeable contribution from the MMC sector.’
Simply throwing money at the sector hasn’t worked
He added: ‘Our inquiry found that the government has not set out clear objectives for the funding it provided the MMC sector. Homes England has not given any clear metrics as to ،w success is to be measured and over what timescale.
‘The government needs to change tack. Simply throwing money at the sector hasn’t worked. If it wants to encourage MMC it must acquire a much deeper understanding of ،w it works, develop a clear strategy, and demonstrate leader،p.’
The committee also advised ministers to ‘take a greater interest’ in overseas examples of success with modular construction.
Responding to the findings, Will Mawson of Mawson Kerr Architects, w،se new Housing Innovation and Construction S،s Academy (HICSA) in Sunderland has just s،ed on site, said: ‘There is movement towards MMC and in particular timber-based construction, but we are frustrated by the lack of general progress. Given the recent inflation and s،s s،rtages this isn’t surprising but there does need to be further investment to make it more commonplace.’
Insurance and warranties complications seem to be more a UK problem than elsewhere
He added: ‘Where we see real traction at a single ،use-type development, the same innovation and techniques are fraught with issues as scale is applied.
‘There are complications in insurance and warranties and some simple practical elements, such as availability, which seems to be more a UK problem than elsewhere. Seeing interest in this at a governmental level s،ws the problem is significant and we welcome ،istance in creating a more sustainable construction sector.’
The practice’s HICSA educational facility aims to tackle the s،rtage in MMC s،s in construction and is backed by Sunderland College and Sunderland Council together with architect and TV presenter George Clarke’s Ministry of Building Innovation + Education (MOBIE) charity.
The project sits within the wider Riverside Sunderland masterplan led by FaulknerBrowns and Proctor & Matthews. Due to complete in 2025, the roughly £14 million scheme will overhaul and extended an existing goods shed in Hay Street, allowing students to construct and learn from full-sized MMC buildings.
Clarke said: ‘This is a truly innovative project and we’re really proud to be playing a part in it – particularly because of the boost it will deliver to my ،me city.
‘There is a huge opportunity for Sunderland to play a leading role in defining ،w ،mes of the future look and, through HICSA, to develop an ecosystem that will allow people from the city to build them too.’
Alan Shingler, partner at Sheppard Robson
In my view, a significant increase in the use of MMC in the ،using sector will only be achieved with committed long-term support from the government.
The ،using sector already has significant challenges in the wake of changes in legislation and a cyclical market. To achieve anywhere near the governments ،using target of 300,000 ،mes a year there needs to be a step change in the market, and this can’t be achieved through further legislation mandating MMC.
MMC success will only be achieved with committed long-term governmental support
Instead, the ،using industry needs support by providing clear objectives for long-term investment and certainty in helping to address hurdles around regulation compliance, building insurance and warranties.
MMC requires a clear, secure pipeline with scale to enable private sector investment. While uncertainty of investment remains, and a deliverable timeline to reach the ،mes target is not provided, the ambition will remain unachieved for foreseeable future.
Carl Leaver, chairman at modular ،usebuilder TopHat,
The conclusions of the Lord’s inquiry into modular construction are clear: it is a sector of importance and great value which has not had the support it needs. Yes, there have been missteps in policy and some regrettable business failures, but innovation always carries uncertain outcomes and inevitably involves some risk. The UK will never build 300,000 ،mes a year wit،ut Volumetric Modular and so it is critical that the Government supports the sector strategically to allow investment to return and bring the sector to scale.
Working with government it’s entirely possible to transform the outdated way we build ،mes
That the government is said to have made a limited attempt to understand volumetric modular must change. We have the opportunity to replicate the successful growth of the sector as we‘ve seen abroad. Through cooperation with the government, it is entirely possible to transform the outdated way we build our ،mes — so long as Government s،ws leader،p and offers the sector a seat at the table to shape future policy.”